The war myth in United States historyHamlin, C. H. (Charles Hunter)
History
The war myth in United States history
Hamlin, C. H. (Charles Hunter)
Propaganda, American; United States -- History; War
(10) The tenth and last cause we shall give of the American
Revolution was the religious cause. There was a movement on foot to
locate an Episcopal bishop in the colonies. At that time all the
clergy of the Episcopal Church were ordained in England as there was
no bishop here. Consequently, all the Episcopal ministers came from
abroad and they were often mediocre, for the more efficient among
them were kept in England. In 1770 there were about two hundred and
fifty Episcopal clergy in the colonies, most of whom were in
Virginia. The rumor of locating a bishop here aroused resentment in
the other denominations who unanimously opposed the plan. But the
most effective religious cause of the Revolution came from still
another source. When Great Britain extended Quebec down between the
Ohio River and the Great Lakes, the Catholic Church was made the
established church of these regions, as it was in Quebec. This
greatly incensed all Protestants and "no pope no king" became one of
the slogans of the Revolution. John Adams considered this religious
animosity "as much as any other a cause" of the war for independence.
Both these attitudes on the part of the colonies were unwise. An
Episcopal bishop was badly needed here to elevate the Episcopal
clergy and remove the unworthy ministers. The prejudice against
Catholics was simply folly. The Catholic priests in the colonies
unanimously supported the Revolution.
If we examine the acts of Great Britain which brought on the
Revolution we find that they were all legal. They were all in
harmony with the spirit of the age. There was simply a general
breakdown of mercantilism. Patrick Henry especially talked about
"rights as British subjects," but there were no such rights of which
the colonies were being deprived. Had they remained in England they
would have enjoyed no privileges of which they were deprived by
coming to America. Talk of this sort made effective oratory, but was
false when examined. "No Taxation without Representation" is not a
legal matter but commonplace political philosophy. We have many
other examples of taxation without representation. The great
majority of people in England were then disfranchised yet taxed.
Women were taxed before they were given the ballot. Many people are
now taxed even in those states where they are deprived of the ballot.
Phrases, as this regarding taxation, were merely effective
generalities without real meaning. The mistake of Great Britain was
not in the passage of any illegal or unusual laws for governing the
colonies, but it was in trying to rule a group of people against
their will. Such a policy invariably invites trouble.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account