Tradition, Principally with Reference to Mythology and the Law of NationsArundell of Wardour, John Francis Arundell, Baron
Philosophy
Tradition, Principally with Reference to Mythology and the Law of Nations
Arundell of Wardour, John Francis Arundell, Baron
International law; Macdonell, George, 1780-1870; Mythology; Natural law; Tradition (Theology)
"If, from one point of view, this is apt to shock a _timorous_
and _unreflecting_ mind, by asserting that the most cherished of
our affections might have been, under _certain_ circumstances, a
vicious piece of self-indulgence, and its place in the scale of
morality taken by what is _now_ the most atrocious kind of crime;
nevertheless, from another point of view, such an assertion is
as reassuring as the most absolute of moralists could desire,
for it is tantamount to saying that the foundations of morality,
the distinctions of right and wrong, are deeply laid in the very
conditions of social existence; that there is, in the face of
these conditions, a positive and definite difference between the
moral and the immoral, the virtuous and the vicious, the right and
the wrong, in the actions of individuals partaking of that social
existence."
This is very well. It is so _now_, because of the traditional
sentiments and principles which still retain their force--but how long
will it continue?
I invite attention to the following passage from Mr Hepworth Dixon's
"New America" (vol. i. p. 312, 6th edition), which I must say struck me
very forcibly when I read it. He narrates a conversation which he had
with Brigham Young on the subject of incest:--"Speaking for himself,
not for the church, he (Brigham Young) said he saw _none at all_
(_i.e._ no objection at all). He added, however, that he would not do
it himself,--'my prejudices prevent me.'" Upon which Mr Hepworth Dixon
observes--
"This _remnant_ of an old feeling brought from the Gentile world,
_and this alone_, would seem to prevent the saints (Mormons) from
rushing into the higher forms of incest. How long will these
Gentile sentiments remain in force? 'You will find here,' said
elder Stenhouse to me, talking on another subject, 'polygamists of
the third generation. When these boys and girls grow up and marry,
you will have in these valleys the _true feeling_ of patriarchal
life. The _old world is about us yet_, and we are always thinking
of what people may say in the Scottish hills and the Midland
shires.'"
Here, and in the previous extract, we seem to catch glimpses of what
the morality of the future is likely to be, at any rate in such matters
as infanticide and incest, if old notions are to be discarded, and
men are left, in each generation, to no higher rule than their own
individual calculation as to pleasure and pain, or to the prevailing
sense or determination of the community as to what the conditions of
utility may permit.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account