Wit and its relation to the unconsciousFreud, Sigmund
Science
Wit and its relation to the unconscious
Freud, Sigmund
Subconsciousness; Wit and humor -- Psychological aspects
“_A wife is like an umbrella, at worst one may also take a cab._”
An umbrella does not afford enough protection from rain. The words “_at
worst_” can mean only: when it is raining hard. A cab is a public
conveyance. As we have to deal here with the figure of comparison, we
shall put off the detailed investigation of this witticism until later
on.
Heine’s “Bäder von Lucca” contains a veritable wasps’ nest of stinging
allusions which make the most artistic use of this form of wit as
polemics against the Count of Platen. Long before the reader can suspect
their application, a certain theme, which does not lend itself
especially to direct presentation, is preluded by allusions of the most
varied material possible; e.g., in Hirsch-Hyacinth’s twisting of words:
You are too corpulent and I am too lean; you possess too much conceit
and I the more business ability; I am a practicus and you are a
diarrheticus, in fine, “You are altogether my Antipodex”—“Venus
Urinia”—the thick Gudel of Dreckwall in Hamburg, etc. Then the
occurrences of which the poet speaks take a turn in which it merely
seems to show the impolite sportiveness of the poet, but soon it
discloses the symbolic relation to the polemical intention, and in this
way it also reveals itself as allusion. At last the attack against
Platen bursts forth, and now the allusions to the subject of the Count’s
love for men seethe and gush from each one of the sentences which Heine
directs against the talent and the character of his opponent, e.g.:
“Even if the Muses are not well disposed to him, he has at least the
genius of speech in his power, or rather he knows how to violate him;
for he lacks the free love of this genius, besides he must perseveringly
run after this youth, and he knows only how to grasp the outer forms
which, in spite of their beautiful rotundity, never express anything
noble.”
“He has the same experience as the ostrich, which considers itself
sufficiently hidden when it sticks its head into the sand so that only
its backside is visible. Our illustrious bird would have done better if
he had stuck his backside into the sand, and had shown us his head.”
Allusion is perhaps the commonest and most easily employed means of wit,
and is at the basis of most of the short-lived witty productions which
we are wont to weave into our conversation. They cannot bear being
separated from their native soil nor can they exist independently. Once
more we are reminded by the process of allusion of that relationship
which has already begun to confuse our estimation of the technique of
wit. The process of allusion is not witty in itself; there are perfectly
formed allusions which have no claims to this character. Only those
allusions which show a “witty” element are witty, hence the
characteristics of wit, which we have followed even into its technique,
again escape us.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account