Feminism in Greek Literature from Homer to Aristotle — Aristotle — John Shaqi
Feminism in Greek Literature from Homer to Aristotle
Aristotle · en
Such were the conditions of Athenian life, and we shall find them
reflected in literature. The great lyric poets, Simonides, Pindar,
Bacchylides, concern themselves almost exclusively with men; Æschylus
alone, in this, as in most things, the exact antithesis of the typical
Athenian, regards women as creatures possessed of mind and soul. In sharp
contrast to the tragedian is Herodotus, and a comparison between their
views is possible, for, although the historian is a considerably younger
man, a good deal of his material goes back to an earlier date, and in
social matters especially he often represents the ideas of the first
years of the fifth century.
Herodotus, great traveller and charming personality though he is, is
still a true Ionian. There is frequently a Milesian flavour about his
tales—for instance the story of Rhampsinitus and the robber—and it is
not unfair to say that in his researches into ancient tribal life and
folklore he is especially interested in such savage customs as put women
in an inferior place. The account of the native races of Libya in the
last chapters of the fourth book of the History will afford an example.
But the grandeur of his main theme, the struggle between Athens and
Persia, raised the historian from these doubtful interests, and in the
last five books of his work there is little depreciation of women as a
class. It is true that women scarcely come into the narrative, and that
Xerxes’ remark about Artemisia, ‘My men have become women and my women
have become men,’ is framed to suit the ideas of an Athenian, as it
would have suited the Romans, who could hardly conceive of a Queen. It
is scarcely as appropriate in the mouth of a Persian whose own mother,
Atossa, was then acting as regent. But this is a small point and,
speaking generally, there is little in the last part of the History to
offend.
Herodotus is really animated by an ardent patriotism and a genuine love
of liberty. ‘Isonomy,’ he says—and many English race-goers will agree
with him—‘the very sound of the word is most excellent.’ But it must be
remembered that his patriotism is for males only, and that his equality
before the law is an equality from which women were shut out; for even
Plato makes isonomy between men and women the last and almost incredible
stage of democratic licence.
So it is in the earlier books alone that the baser manner is evident, and
one example of it will suffice to give a proof of the difference between
the Ionian spirit which brought about the enslavement of women and the
spirit of enlightenment which rebelled against that servitude.