The Philosophy of Fine Art, volume 4 (of 4): Hegel's Aesthetik
Georg Hegel · en
The tragic issue does not, however, require in every case as a means
of removing both over-emphasized aspects and the equal honour which
they respectively claim the downfall of the contestant parties. The
"Eumenides" does not end, as we all know, with the death of Orestes,
or the destruction of the Eumenides, these avenging spirits of
matricide and filial affection, these opponents of Apollo, who seeks
to protect unimpaired the worth of and reverence for the family chief
and king, the god who had prompted Orestes to slay Clytaemnestra, but
will have Orestes released from the punishment and honour bestowed
on both himself and the Furies. At the same time we cannot fail to
see in this adjusted conclusion the nature of the authority which
the Greeks attached to their gods when they presented them as mere
individuals contending with each other. They appear, in short, to
the Athenian of everyday life merely as definite aspects of ethical
experience which the principles of morality viewed in their complete
and harmonious coherence bind together. The votes of the Areopagus are
equal on either side. It is Athene, the goddess, the life of Athens,
that is, imagined in its essential unity, who adds the white pebble,
who frees Orestes, and at the same time promises altars and a cult
to the Eumenides no less than Apollo. As a contrast to this type of
objective reconciliation the settlement may be, _secondly_, of a more
personal character. In other words, the individual concerned in the
action may in the last instance surrender his onesided point of view.
In this betrayal by personality of its essential pathos, however, it
cannot fail to appear destitute of character; and this contradicts the
masculine integrity of such plastic figures. The individual, therefore,
can only submit to a higher Power and its counsel or command, to the
effect that while on his own account he adheres to such a pathos, the
will is nevertheless broken in its bare obstinacy by a god's authority.
In such a case the knot is not loosened, but, as in the case of
Philoctetes, it is severed by a _deus ex machinâ._