The English works of Thomas Hobbes of Malmesbury, Volume 01 (of 11) — Thomas Hobbes — John Shaqi
The English works of Thomas Hobbes of Malmesbury, Volume 01 (of 11)
Thomas Hobbes · en
10. But when we seek after the cause of any propounded effect, we must
in the first place get into our mind an exact notion or idea of that
which we call cause, namely, that _a cause is the sum or aggregate of
all such accidents, both in the agents and the patient, as concur to the
producing of the effect propounded; all which existing together, it
cannot be understood but that the effect existeth with them; or that it
can possibly exist if any one of them be absent_. This being known, in
the next place we must examine singly every accident that accompanies or
precedes the effect, as far forth as it seems to conduce in any manner
to the production of the same, and see whether the propounded effect may
be conceived to exist, without the existence of any of those accidents;
and by this means separate such accidents, as do not concur, from such
as concur to produce the said effect; which being done, we are to put
together the concurring accidents, and consider whether we can possibly
conceive, that when these are all present, the effect propounded will
not follow; and if it be evident that the effect will follow, then that
aggregate of accidents is the entire cause, otherwise not; but we must
still search out and put together other accidents. For example, if the
cause of light be propounded to be sought out; first, we examine things
without us, and find that whensoever light appears, there is some
principal object, as it were the fountain of light, without which we
cannot have any perception of light; and, therefore, the concurrence of
that object is necessary to the generation of light. Next we consider
the medium, and find, that unless it be disposed in a certain manner,
namely, that it be transparent, though the object remain the same, yet
the effect will not follow; and, therefore, the concurrence of
transparency is also necessary to the generation of light. Thirdly, we
observe our own body, and find that by the indisposition of the eyes,
the brain, the nerves, and the heart, that is, by obstructions,
stupidity, and debility, we are deprived of light, so that a fitting
disposition of the organs to receive impressions from without is
likewise a necessary part of the cause of light. Again, of all the
accidents inherent in the object, there is none that can conduce to the
effecting of light, but only action (or a certain motion), which cannot
be conceived to be wanting, whensoever the effect is present; for, that
anything may shine, it is not requisite that it be of such or such
magnitude or figure, or that the whole body of it be moved out of the
place it is in (unless it may perhaps be said, that in the sun, or other
body, that which causes light is the light it hath in itself; which yet
is but a trifling exception, seeing nothing is meant thereby but the
cause of light; as if any man should say that the cause of light is that
in the sun which produceth it); it remains, therefore, that the action,