The English works of Thomas Hobbes of Malmesbury, Volume 02 (of 11) — Thomas Hobbes — John Shaqi
The English works of Thomas Hobbes of Malmesbury, Volume 02 (of 11)
Thomas Hobbes · en
_Judge what opinions, &c._ There is scarce any principle, neither
in the worship of God nor in human sciences, from whence there may
not spring dissensions, discords, reproaches, and by degrees war
itself. Neither doth this happen by reason of the falsehood of the
principle, but of the disposition of men, who, seeming wise to
themselves, will needs appear such to all others. But though such
dissensions cannot be hindered from arising, yet may they be
restrained by the exercise of the supreme power, that they prove
no hindrance to the public peace. Of these kinds of opinions,
therefore, I have not spoken in this place. There are certain
doctrines wherewith subjects being tainted, they verily believe
that obedience may be refused to the city, and that by right they
may, nay ought, to oppose and fight against chief princes and
dignities. Such are those which, whether directly and openly, or
more obscurely and by consequence, require obedience to be given
to others beside them to whom the supreme authority is committed.
I deny not but this reflects on that power which many, living
under other government, ascribe to the chief head of the Church of
Rome, and also on that which elsewhere, out of that Church,
bishops require in their’s to be given to them; and last of all,
on that liberty which the lower sort of citizens, under pretence
of religion, do challenge to themselves. For what civil war was
there ever in the Christian world, which did not either grow from,
or was nourished by this root? The judgment therefore of
doctrines, whether they be repugnant to civil obedience or not,
and if they be repugnant, the power of prohibiting them to be
taught, I do here attribute to the civil authority. For since
there is no man who grants not to the city the judgment of those
things which belong to its peace and defence, and it is manifest
that the opinions which I have already recited do relate to its
peace; it follows necessarily, that the examination of those
opinions, whether they be such or not, must be referred to the
city; that is, to him who hath the supreme authority.
[Sidenote: Whatsoever he doth is unpunishable.]
12. Last of all, from this consideration, that each citizen hath
submitted his will to his who hath the supreme command in the city,
so as he may not employ his strength against him; it follows
manifestly, that whatsoever shall be done by him who commands, must
not be punished. For as he who hath not power enough, cannot punish
him naturally, so neither can he punish him by right, who by right
hath not sufficient power.
[Sidenote: That he hath an absolute dominion granted him by his
citizens, and what proportion of obedience is due unto
him.]