The English works of Thomas Hobbes of Malmesbury, Volume 05 (of 11)
Thomas Hobbes · en
(_k_) “He adds further, that ‘as the end is necessary, so are the means;
and when it is determined that one thing shall be chosen before another,
it is determined also for what cause it shall be so chosen.’ All which
is truth, but not the whole truth; for as God ordains means for all
ends, so he adapts and fits the means to their respective ends, free
means to free ends, contingent means to contingent ends, necessary means
to necessary ends, whereas T. H. would have all means, all ends, to be
necessary. If God hath so ordered the world, that a man ought to use,
and may freely use, those means of God, which he doth neglect, not by
virtue of God’s decree, but by his own fault; if a man use those means
of evil, which he ought not to use, and which by God’s decree he had
power to forbear; if God have left to man in part the free managery of
human affairs, and to that purpose hath endowed him with understanding:
then consultations are of use, then provident care is needful, then it
concerns him to use the means. But if God have so ordered this world,
that a man cannot, if he would, neglect any means of good, which by
virtue of God’s decree it is possible for him to use, and that he cannot
possibly use any means of evil, but those which are irresistibly and
inevitably imposed upon him by an antecedent decree; then not only
consultations are vain, but that noble faculty of reason itself is vain.
Do we think that we can help God Almighty to do his proper work? In vain
we trouble ourselves, in vain we take care to use those means, which are
not in our power to use, or not to use. And this is that which was
contained in my prolepsis or prevention of his answer, though he be
pleased both to disorder it, and to silence it. We cannot hope by our
labours, to alter the course of things set down by God; let him perform
his decree, let the necessary causes do their work. If we be those
causes, yet we are not in our own disposition; we must do what we are
ordained to do, and more we cannot do. Man hath no remedy but patience,
and to shrug up the shoulders. This is the doctrine that flows from this
opinion of absolute necessity. Let us suppose the great wheel of the
clock which sets all the little wheels going, to be as the decree of
God, and that the motion of it were perpetually infallible from an
intrinsical principle, even as God’s decree is infallible, eternal,
all-sufficient. Let us suppose the lesser wheels to be the second
causes, and that they do as certainly follow the motion of the great
wheel, without missing or swerving in the least degree, as the second
causes do pursue the determination of the first cause. I desire to know
in this case, what cause there is to call a council of smiths, to
consult and order the motion of that which was ordered and determined
before to their hands? Are men wiser than God? Yet all men know, that
the motion of the lesser wheels is a necessary means to make the clock
strike.