The English works of Thomas Hobbes of Malmesbury, Volume 05 (of 11) — Thomas Hobbes — John Shaqi
The English works of Thomas Hobbes of Malmesbury, Volume 05 (of 11)
Thomas Hobbes · en
“Besides these mistakes and contradictions, he hath other errors also in
this section. As this, that no actions proceeding from fear are
spontaneous. He who throws his goods into the sea to avoid drowning,
doth it not only _spontaneously_, but even _freely_. He that wills the
end, wills the means conducing to that end. It is true that if the
action be considered nakedly without all circumstances, no man willingly
or spontaneously casts his goods into the sea. But if we take the
action, as in this particular case, invested with all the circumstances,
and in order to the end, that is, the saving of his own life, it is not
only voluntary and spontaneous, but elective and chosen by him, as the
most probable means for his own preservation. As there is an antecedent
and a subsequent will, so there is an antecedent and a subsequent
spontaneity. His grammatical argument, grounded upon the derivation of
spontaneous from _sponte_, weighs nothing; we have learned in the
rudiments of logic, that conjugates are sometimes in name only, and not
in deed. He who casts his goods into the sea, may do it of his own
accord in order to the end. Secondly, he errs in this also, that nothing
is opposed to spontaneity but only fear. Invincible and antecedent
ignorance doth destroy the nature of spontaneity or voluntariness, by
removing that knowledge which should and would have prohibited the
action. As a man thinking to shoot a wild beast in a bush, shoots his
friend, which if he had known, he would not have shot. This man did not
kill his friend of his own accord.