The English works of Thomas Hobbes of Malmesbury, Volume 07 (of 11)
Thomas Hobbes · en
The eighteenth article is this, “_in any parallelogram, if the two sides
that contain the angle be moved to their opposite sides, the one
uniformly, the other uniformly accelerated; the side that is moved
uniformly, by its concourse through all its longitude, hath the same
effect which it would have if the other motion were also uniform, and
the line described were a mean proportional between the whole length,
and the half of the same_.”
To the proposition you object first, “_that it is all one whether the
other motion be uniform or not, because the effect of each of their
motions, is but to carry the body to the opposite side_.” But do you
think that whatsoever be the motions, the body shall be carried by their
concourse always to the same point of the opposite side? If not, then
the effect is not all one when a motion is made by the concourse of two
motions uniform and accelerated, and when it is made by the concourse of
two uniform or of two accelerated motions.
Secondly, you say that these words, _and the line described were a mean
proportional between the whole length, and the half of the same_, have
no sense, or that you are deceived. True. For you are deceived; or
rather you have not understanding enough distinctly to conceive variety
of motions though distinctly expressed. For when a line is gone over
with motion uniformly accelerated, you cannot understand how a mean
proportional can be taken between it and its half; or if you can, you
cannot conceive that that mean can be gone over with uniform motion in
the same time that the whole line was run over by motion uniformly
accelerated. Yet these are things conceivable, and your want of
understanding must be made my fault.