The English works of Thomas Hobbes of Malmesbury, Volume 07 (of 11)
Thomas Hobbes · en
When the author of the paper wherein I am called Plagiary, and wherein
the honour is taken from you of being the first inventor of these fine
theorems, shall read this that I have here written, he will look to get
no credit by it; especially if it be Roberval, which methinks it should
not be. For he understands what proportion is, better than to make 5 to
4 the same with 1 to 12. Or to make, again, the proportion of 36 to 27
the same with that of 1 to 12; and innumerable _disproportionalites_
that may be inferred from the grounds you go on. But if it be Roberval
indeed, that snatches this invention from you, when he shall see this
burning coal hanging at it, he will let it fall again, for fear of
spoiling his reputation.
But what shall I answer to the authority of the three great
mathematicians that sent you those encomiastic letters. For the first,
whom you say I use to praise, I shall take better heed hereafter of
praising any man for his learning whilst he is young, further than that
he is in a good way. But it seems he was in too ready a way of thinking
very well of himself, as you do of yourself. For the muddiness of my
brain I must confess it; but, Sir, ought not you to confess the same of
yours? No, men of your tenets use not to do so. He wonders, say you, you
thought it worth the while to foul your fingers about such a piece. It
is well; every man abounds in his own sense. If you and I were to be
compared by the compliments that are given us in private letters, both
you and your complimentors would be out of countenance; which
compliments, besides that which has been printed and published in the
commendations of my writings, if it were put together, would make a
greater volume than either of your libels. And truly, Sir, I had never
answered your Elenchus as proceeding from Dr. Wallis, if I had not
considered you also as the minister to execute the malice of that sort
of people that are offended with my _Leviathan_.
As for the judgment of that public Professor that makes himself a
witness of the goodness of your geometry, a man may easily see by the
letter itself that he is a dunce. And for the English person of quality
whom I know not, I can say no more yet than I can say of all three, that
he is so ill a geometrician, as not to detect those gross paralogisms as
infer that 5 to 4 and 1 to 12 are the same proportion. He came into the
cry of those whom your title had deceived.