Femina, A Work for Every Woman — John Stuart Mill — John Shaqi
Femina, A Work for Every Woman
John Stuart Mill · en
There must be a _standard of excellence_ established by the State,
which is higher than and above the recognized standard of any medical
college, for no medical college is trustworthy in this respect.
The State in its sovereignty must prescribe what shall constitute
a medical education, and the requirements should be embodied in
the statutes. A license or degree from that source, after a final
examination, should be the only legitimate license to practice medicine.
Such a method would establish a system that would clearly define the
status of every medical practitioner. The board must have the power,
and it must be their duty, to examine each and every applicant for a
license, as all candidates for the army medical service are examined.
All this noise and talk about a preliminary examination and an extended
course of medical study are simply the vaporings of superficial minds.
It is neither the preliminary course, nor the length of time that a
person consumes in trying to become a doctor, in which the public
is interested, but what kind of doctor a person is when he hangs
out his shingle and begins to practice, whether he is competent to
do that which is expected from him in the hour of sickness or great
peril, irrespective of any diploma or any medical college. Foreign
graduates should be amenable to the same examination, for behind
these, too, belongs the interrogation point. The gushing mediocrity of
some of these diploma holders gives rise to the suspicion that their
credentials are not genuine.
As an American to the manor born, I would not for a moment deny the
humblest citizen an opportunity to elevate himself to the highest
professional honors; but why can he not be required to thoroughly equip
himself and prove, by oral and written examinations on subjects of
preliminary education, that his mind has become disciplined for broader
or special studies, irrespective of any course in a college? After
the State has satisfied itself of the proficiency of the applicant in
scholastic acquirements, it should go further, and examine into the
qualifications for a degree of medicine, just as they do in the _U. S.
Army_, only with this exception, that no diploma of any medical college
should be required from the candidate, and if he has one it should not
be recognized.
This would simply incorporate in the State laws the distinctive feature
of the University of London, which examines and confers graduation on
persons who have received instruction in such institutions at home and
in the colonies as have satisfied a Secretary of State with regard to
their studies.