Femina, A Work for Every Woman — John Stuart Mill — John Shaqi
Femina, A Work for Every Woman
John Stuart Mill · en
thoroughly competent and scientific and manufacture no diseases to suit
emergencies nor conjure up complaints that have no real existence. If
their number were doubled, if the normal proportion were disturbed,
the _disaster_ would surely follow, professional demoralization would
ensue. So the German profession sounds a timely note of warning ere the
canker of selfishness has destroyed the noble altruistic principles of
physicians, without which the doctor is as likely to be a messenger
from hell as a ministering servant from heaven.
Medical legislation in this country has been nothing less than a
farce, partly because the general public is not aware how abased the
profession is, and partly that Americans are extremely jealous of what
they term personal liberty. It is being attempted to remedy some of
the abuses of the medical profession by regulating the practice of
medicine by State Examining Boards. Experience has demonstrated that
these boards are but the excrescences of the various medical colleges,
who are themselves the root of the very evils that are sought to be
remedied. The duties of these boards are simply to make themselves
officious, and to inquire into the source of the credentials or
diplomas of the applicants for a license to practice medicine, and
not into the qualifications or competency of the applicants. All that
is necessary under such laws is simply to present a diploma of some
sort; whether it was stolen, or the diploma of a dead man, or gotten
from any of the numerous worthless colleges, is not made the subject
of inquiry; and as by far the greatest number of quack-salvers in this
country have diplomas, the law falls short of remedying quackery.
There are, usually, enough boards of examiners, representing the
different schools, so that the different interests of the diploma
manufacturers are well represented. A medical examining authority whose
functions and powers do not go higher or beyond the mere granting of
licenses, or which does not examine into the qualifications of the
persons who possess diplomas, is utterly absurd, because it is no
protection against ignorance and imposition. A law that presumes that
all persons holding diplomas are qualified and competent to practice
medicine, is essentially wrong, or inadequate to fulfill the purpose
for which it was designed. I have known graduates from what were
considered good colleges who could neither write a safe prescription
nor diagnose a case.
There is only one way towards an approach to an efficient and
intelligent board of medical examiners, and that is, one single State
board in which the different schools may be represented as to their
pet theories of prescribing medicines, but in all other departments
of medical science and art there must be a uniformity of talent and
qualification.