Revolving lights : $b Pilgrimage, Volume 7 — John Stuart Mill — John Shaqi
Revolving lights : $b Pilgrimage, Volume 7
John Stuart Mill · en
But it is another kind of question that is meant, the question that is a
direct attack on the unseeing gaze; a speech to the man at the wheel.
That is where, without knowing it, these people are philosophers. What
Socrates saw, answered all his questions; and his counterings of the
young men's questions were invitations to them to look for themselves.
The single world these people see is, to them, so unquestionable that
there is no room for question. Nothing can be communicated except the
latest news; and scandal; information about people who have gone outside
the shape. But, to each other, even their statements are put in the form
of questions. "Fine day, what?" So that everyone may be not questioned,
but questioner. It is also a sort of apology for falling into speech at
all.
It was Michael Shatov's amused delight in her stories of their method
that had made her begin to cherish them as a possession. Gradually she
had learned that irritation with their apparent insolence was jealousy.
Within her early interested unenvious sallies of investigation amongst
the social élite of the Wimpole Street patients, or as a fellow guest
amongst the Orlys' society friends, there had been moments of longing to
sweep away the defences and discountenance the individual. But gradually
the conviction had dawned that with the genuine members of the clan this
could not be done. Their quality went right through, shedding its
central light, a brightness that could not be encircled, over the whole
of humanity. They disarmed attack, because in their singleness of nature
they were not aware of anything to defend. They had no contempts; not
being specially intellectual; and, crediting everyone with their own
condition, they reached to the sources of nobility in all with whom they
came in contact. It was refreshment and joy merely to be in the room
with them. But also it was an arduous exercise. They brought such a wide
picture and so long a history. They were England. The world-wide spread
of Christian England was in their minds; and to this they kindled, more
than to any personal thing.
The existence of these scattered few, explained those who were only
conventional approximations....
To-night, immersed in the vision of a future that threatened their
world, she found them one and all bright figures of romance. She sped as
her footsteps measured off the length of the little street, into the
recesses, the fair and the evil, of aristocratic English life, and
affectionately followed the small bright freely moving troupe as it
spread in the past and was at this moment spreading, abroad over the
world, the unchangeable English quality and its attendant conventions.