The golden windmill, and other stories — John Stuart Mill — John Shaqi
The golden windmill, and other stories
John Stuart Mill · en
As you know, it is considered rather provocative to launch a book of
short stories. It is asking for trouble. The least I can do is to offer
a brief apology; and I cannot do this without writing a preface, which
requires an apology in itself. Unless you are a Bernard Shaw you find a
preface a most embarrassing business. Having written the stories I would
rather talk about anything else—old furniture, for instance. Perhaps my
best policy will be to start by attacking you, O Reader, friend or enemy,
as the case may be. You are a most exacting fellow. Far more exacting
than a reader of novels, or works of reference, or even histories; for
the reason that your criticism follows a more circumscribed tradition.
You are a kind of gourmet whose palate is acutely sensitive to accustomed
flavors and satieties. It is always easier to be an epicure of a small
repast than of a banquet. A novel is less easily digested. You may
enjoy it in parts, or derive satisfaction from the matter, or from the
manner of telling, but with a short story you require a _bonne bouche_.
You have a most arbitrary standard. When you raise your eyes from
the last line you pass through a most peculiar mental process. It all
takes place in a few seconds. In a flash you see the shape and form and
color, the application of the title, the _point_ of the whole thing.
You demand this, and you also demand to have your senses tickled by
some cunning solution, and to be soothed by something unexpected at the
close. You observe it as a whole, in the same way that you would observe
a water-color sketch, or a Sheraton chair. You may afterwards further
examine the sketch, and even sit on the chair, but their appeal to you
depends on that first glance. Otherwise you turn away, a dissatisfied and
disgruntled gourmet. To-morrow you will dine elsewhere. The truth is your
sense of tradition had been outraged.