The golden windmill, and other stories — John Stuart Mill — John Shaqi
The golden windmill, and other stories
John Stuart Mill · en
Fortunately for you, and for me, tradition is a fine thing. Nothing
comes out of the blue, except perhaps thunderbolts and they are
not really very useful things, certainly no good to any one trying
to create. Chippendale, Sheraton, or Heppelwhite were all men of
strong individuality. You could never mistake a Sheraton chair for a
Chippendale, or a Chippendale for a Heppelwhite; and yet they were all
craftsmen who worked on strictly traditional lines. The same may be said
of Turgenev, Guy de Maupassant, Joseph Conrad and Tchekoff. Please do not
think that I am mentioning my own short stories in the same breath with
the stories of these giants. I only want to point out to you that those
of us who desire to write them have a noble tradition to follow. You may
argue that the analogy between the making of a chair and the creation
of a short story is rather far-fetched for the reason that the plan of
a chair has long since been fixed and determined by the nature of the
seated attitude; that until we find a new way of sitting down the plan
of the chair must remain the same; whereas the short story may wander at
random over the wide fields of human nature. To this I will reply—Has
human nature altered perceptibly more than the nature of the seated
attitude? You are bound to agree with me that it hasn’t. The Arabs—who
have always been the best story tellers—have stated that there are only
seven stories in the world. The complications of what is called Social
Progress have not increased the number. They have rather restricted it.
The emotions can do no more with dollars and girders than they used to be
able to do with magic carpets and languishing houris. People love, hate,
struggle and fructify, and to set down their story is a nice respectable
craft with a fine old tradition—very like chairmaking.
The two crafts have another point in common. It is the business of them
both to make you comfortable. When I start reading a story by Tchekoff
I feel comfortable at once. On quite a different plane I feel the same
with that remarkable story-teller, O. Henry. They may shock me, or thrill
me, or delight me, but I know it’s going to be all right. My sense of
tradition will not be outraged. Tchekoff may give me that accustomed
sense of satiety by a mere turn of a phrase; O. Henry by some amazing
double surprise. But I know all the time that there will be nothing to
worry about.
In these stories, then, I have merely tried to be a good apprentice to
skilled craftsmen. I claim for them no originality at all. Though their
setting is entirely modern, and they deal with such things as fried-fish
shops, and public-houses, and the like, they are just the same old seven
stories told in the bazaars of Ispahan three thousand years ago.