The mill house mystery — John Stuart Mill — John Shaqi
The mill house mystery
John Stuart Mill · en
“There you are then. Confound you!” growled he, as he turned quickly
away with the empty case.
Rhoda’s brain reeled again.
She knew that she had got the Romney safe in her arms.
CHAPTER XI.
THE PICTURE RECOVERED
In the half-dark passage Rhoda stood, alone, when Jack Rotherfield
had left her, uncertain what to do.
The first impulse of thankfulness and delight, in the thought that she
had rescued Sir Robert’s favourite picture, that in a few moments he
would be congratulating himself on its safe return, was quickly
succeeded by a feeling of horror, of dread, when she realised the
ever-increasing difficulties of her own position.
What should she say to him? How should she explain the manner in which
she had obtained possession of the lost treasure?
To tell the whole truth was, for many reasons, out of the question.
In the first place, Jack Rotherfield, in asking her her terms, had, as
it were, bound her in honour not to betray him; and, although she now
appreciated the fact that, in keeping silence, she would be
compounding a felony, she did not know what else to do.
Certainly Jack deserved to be denounced as a thief, and a traitor to
his best friend. Remembering the horrible affair of ten years before,
and that he had been concerned in it, she recognised that he must be a
man wholly without conscience or sense of honour, since he could rob
his best friend, deceive him, and even incur the guilt of a worse
crime.
Whether the death of poor Langton were the result of murder or
manslaughter, the silence of the man who had caused it gave reason for
the worst suspicions.
But that was not by any means the whole of the difficulty. Even
supposing that Rhoda had felt it her duty to denounce Jack to Sir
Robert, regardless of the tacit obligation she was now under to be
silent about his share in the theft of the picture, how could she take
upon herself to open up such a disastrous series of questions as the
baronet would naturally ask? How could she undertake the task of
enlightening him as to the extent to which his own wife was involved
in the deception which had been practised upon him?
And that it would be impossible to denounce Jack Rotherfield without
involving Lady Sarah she felt sure.
Investigations would be made, interrogatories instituted, which would
end in complete discovery. Even short of that, Rhoda doubted whether
Lady Sarah would suffer her accomplice to be found guilty without
confessing, tacitly or otherwise, to her share in his guilt.
But granted that even that difficulty were safely surmounted, and Jack
Rotherfield ostracised, would not the result have consequences to be
dreaded?
If Sir Robert were once to learn of the theft, he would certainly go
on to learn the share Jack had had in the murder of the servant. And
what questions would then be asked? What revelations would be made?