The old South : $b A monograph — John Stuart Mill — John Shaqi
The old South : $b A monograph
John Stuart Mill · en
Side by side with the aristocrat, waiting deferentially to do his
bidding, with a grace and courtliness hardly surpassed by his master,
I place the negro servant of the Old South. If one figure was unique,
the other is not less so. Either figure in the passing throng would
quickly arrest your attention. I am frank to confess to a tender
feeling for those faithful black servitors of the Old South—the
“Uncle Remuses” and “Aunt Chloes” of picture and poetry. On the
great plantations, in their picturesque colors, in constant laughter
and good nature, well fed and clothed and generally well-kept
and moderately worked, the negro of slavery lived his careless,
heart-free life. The specter of hunger and want never disquieted him.
His cabin, clothing, food, garden, pocket money, and holidays came
without his concern. I think I state the truth when I say that for
the millions of slaves of the Old South there were fewer heartaches
than ever troubled a race of people. Freedom may be an inestimable
boon. I know that poet and orator have so declared. But when I look
upon the care-worn faces of the remnant of old-time negroes who have
been testing freedom for a generation and have found it full of
heartache and worry, I take exception to the much-vaunted doctrine of
liberty as the panacea for all human ills. An old darky, with white
head and shuffling feet and haunted look in his eyes, stopped the
other day at the door of my office, and, after the manner of the old
days, his cap in hand, asked “if massa could give the old nigger a
dime?” Something in my voice or manner must have intimated to him
that, like him, I belonged to the old order, as he said: “It’s all
right for some folks, dis thing they calls freedom; but God knows
I’d be glad to see the old days once more before I die.” Freedom to
him, and to others like him, had proven a cheat and a snare. I have
no word of apology or defense for slavery. Long ago I thanked God
that it was no longer lawful for one human being to hold another in
enforced servitude. But a generation or more of free negroes has been
our most familiar object-lesson, and the outcome is painful at best.
The negro who commands respect in the South to-day, as a rule, is the
negro who was born and trained under slavery. The new generation,
those who have known nothing but freedom, it is charity to say,
are an unsatisfactory body of people generally. Whenever you find
a negro whose education comes not from books and college only, but
from the example and home teaching and training of his white master
and mistress, you will generally find one who speaks the truth, is
honest, self-respecting and self-restraining, docile and reverent,
and always the friend of the Southern white gentleman and lady.
Here and there in the homes of the New South these graduates from
the school of slavery are to be found in the service of old families
and their descendants, and the relationship is one of peculiar