Thunder and Lightning — John Stuart Mill — John Shaqi
Thunder and Lightning
John Stuart Mill · en
Generally the people who are struck fall at once without a struggle.
It has been proved by a great number of observations that the man who
has been struck by lightning so as to lose consciousness immediately
falls without having seen, heard, or felt anything. This is easy to
believe, since electricity is animated by a movement much quicker than
that of light, and still more so than that of sound. The eye and ear
are paralyzed before the lightning and the thunder could have made an
impression on them; so much so that the victims, when they recover
themselves, are unable to explain what has happened to them.
People struck by lightning nearly always sink on the very spot where
they have been struck. Besides this, we have already remarked several
cases where the people struck have preserved the exact positions they
had at the moment of the catastrophe.
But, on the other hand, we can quote some examples, rarer, but
diametrically opposed to these.
On July 8, 1839, lightning struck an oak near Triel (Seine-et-Oise),
and also struck two quarrymen, father and son. This last was killed
dead, raised, and transported twenty-three yards away.
The surgeon Brillouet was surprised by a storm near Chantilly, and was
raised by the lightning and deposited twenty-five paces from where he
had been.
On August 18, 1884, at Namur (Belgium), a man was flung ten yards from
the tree under which he had been struck by lightning.
The following notice was in the papers in August, 1900:--
"Brousses-et-Villaret (Aude), August 20. During the storm which burst
over that region the lightning killed two cows belonging to M.
Bouchère. It also struck, but without hurting him, a young man of
twenty-three years of age, Bernard Robart, artilleryman, who was
taking a holiday. He was walking to a neighbouring farm when he was
suddenly carried through the air for fifty yards. He got up again
without any hurt, only he was dazzled by the lightning which had
flashed before his eyes."
On writing to the victim to verify this fact, I received the following
answer:--
"I have the honour to inform you that the article relating to
the incident which happened to me during the lightning, on
the 17th, is absolutely true.