Plato and the Other Companions of Sokrates, 3rd ed. Volume 4 — Plato — John Shaqi
Plato and the Other Companions of Sokrates, 3rd ed. Volume 4
Plato · en
Plato conceives the Gods according to the exigencies of his own
mind--complete discord with those of the popular mind 163
Repugnance of ordinary Athenians in regard to the criticism of
Sokrates on the religious legends 165
Aristophanes connects the idea of immorality with the freethinkers
and their wicked misinterpretations _ib._
Heresies ascribed to Sokrates by his own friends--Unpopularity of
his name from this circumstance 168
Restrictions imposed by Plato upon musical modes and reciters
_ib._
All these restrictions intended for the emotional training of the
Guardians 169
Regulations for the life of the Guardians, especially the
prohibition of separate property and family _ib._
Purpose of Plato in these regulations _ib._
Common life, education, drill, collective life, and duties, for
Guardians of both sexes. Views of Plato respecting the female
character and aptitudes 171
His arguments against the ordinary doctrine 172
Opponents appealed to nature as an authority against Plato. He
invokes Nature on his own side against them 173
Collective family relations and denominations among the
Guardians 174
Restrictions upon sexual intercourse--Purposes of such
restrictions 175
Regulations about marriages and family 176
Procreative powers of individual Guardians required to be held at
the disposal of the rulers, for purity of breed 177
Purpose to create an intimate and equal sympathy among all the
Guardians, but to prevent exclusive sympathy of particular members
178
Platonic scheme--partial communism 179
Soldiership as a separate profession has acquired greater
development in modern times 180
Spartan institutions--great impression which they produced upon
speculative Greek minds 181
Plans of these speculative minds compared with Spartan--Different
types of character contemplated 182
Plato carries abstraction farther than Xenophon or Aristotle 183
Anxiety shown by Plato for the good treatment of the Demos,
greater than that shown by Xenophon and Aristotle _ib._
In Aristotle's theory, the Demos are not considered as members of
the Commonwealth, but as adjuncts 184
Objection urged by Aristotle against the Platonic Republic, that
it will be two cities. Spiritual pride of the Guardians, contempt
for the Demos _ib._
Plato's scheme fails, mainly because he provides no training for
the Demos 186
Principle of Aristotle--That every citizen belongs to the city,
not to himself--applied by Plato to women 187
Aristotle declares the Platonic Commonwealth impossible--In what
sense this is true 189
The real impossibility of the Platonic Commonwealth, arises from
the fact that discordant sentiments are already established 191
Plato has strong feelings of right and wrong about sexual
intercourse, but referring to different objects 192
Different sentiment which would grow up in the Platonic
Commonwealth respecting the sexual relations 193