Plato and the Other Companions of Sokrates, 3rd ed. Volume 4 — Plato — John Shaqi
Plato and the Other Companions of Sokrates, 3rd ed. Volume 4
Plato · en
What Nature prescribes in regard to the relations of the two
sexes--Direct contradiction between Plato and Aristotle 194
Opinion of Plato respecting the capacities of women, and the
training proper for women, are maintained in the Leges, as well as
in the Republic. Ancient legends harmonising with this opinion
195
In a Commonwealth like the Platonic, the influence of Aphroditê
would probably have been reduced to a minimum 197
Other purposes of Plato--limitation of number of Guardians--common
to Aristotle also 198
Law of population expounded by Malthus--Three distinct checks to
population--alternative open between preventive and positive
_ib._
Plato and Aristotle saw the same law as Malthus, but arranged the
facts under a different point of view 202
Regulations of Plato and Aristotle as to number of births and
newborn children _ib._
Such regulations disapproved and forbidden by modern sentiment.
Variability of ethical sentiment as to objects approved or
disapproved 203
Plato and Aristotle required subordination of impulse to reason
and duty--they applied this to the procreative impulse, as to
others 204
Training of the few select philosophers to act as chiefs 205
Comprehensive curriculum for aspirants to philosophy--consummation
by means of Dialectic 206
Valuable remarks on the effects of these preparatory studies 207
Differences between the Republic and other dialogues--no mention
of reminiscence nor of the Elenchus _ib._
Different view taken by Plato in the Republic about Dialectic--and
different place assigned to it 208
Contradiction with the spirit of other dialogues Parmenidês,
&c. 209
Contradiction with the character and declarations of Sokrates
210
The remarks here made upon the effect of Dialectic upon youth
coincide with the accusation of Melêtus against Sokrates
211
Contrast between the real Sokrates, as a dissenter at Athens, and
the Platonic Sokrates, framer and dictator of the Platonic
Republic _ib._
Idea of Good--The Chiefs alone know what it is--If they did not
they would be unfit for their functions 212
What is the Good? Plato does not know; but he requires the Chiefs
to know it. Without this the Republic would be a failure 213
CHAPTER XXXVIII.
TIMÆUS AND KRITIAS.
Persons and scheme of the Timæus and Kritias 215
The Timæus is the earliest ancient physical theory, which we
possess in the words of its author 216
Position and character of the Pythagorean Timæus _ib._
Poetical imagination displayed by Plato. He pretends to nothing
more than probability. Contrast with Sokrates, Isokrates, Xenophon
217
Fundamental distinction between Ens and Fientia 219
Postulates of Plato. The Demiurgus--The Eternal Ideas--Chaotic
Materia or Fundamentum. The Kosmos is a living being and a God
220
The Demiurgus not a Creator--The Kosmos arises from his operating
upon the random movements of Necessity. He cannot controul
necessity--he only persuades _ib._