The dialogues of Plato in five volumes, Vol. 2 (of 5) : $b Translated into English with analyses and introductions
Plato · en
The three myths are unlike anything else in Plato. There is an Oriental,
or rather an Egyptian element in them, and they have an affinity to
the mysteries and to the Orphic modes of worship. To a certain extent
they are un-Greek; at any rate there is hardly anything like them in
other Greek writings which have a serious purpose; in spirit they are
mediaeval. They are akin to what may be termed the underground religion
in all ages and countries. They are presented in the most lively and
graphic manner, but they are never insisted on as true; it is only
affirmed that nothing better can be said about a future life. Plato seems
to make use of them when he has reached the limits of human knowledge;
or, to borrow an expression of his own, when he is standing on the
outside of the intellectual world. They are very simple in style; a few
touches bring the picture home to the mind, and make it present to us.
They have also a kind of authority gained by the employment of sacred and
familiar names, just as mere fragments of the words of Scripture, put
together in any form and applied to any subject, have a power of their
own. They are a substitute for poetry and mythology; and they are also a
reform of mythology. The moral of them may be summed up in a word or two:
After death the Judgment; and ‘there is some better thing remaining for
the good than for the evil.’
All literature gathers into itself many elements of the past: for
example, the tale of the earth-born men in the Republic appears at
first sight to be an extravagant fancy, but it is restored to propriety
when we remember that it is based on a legendary belief. The art of
making stories of ghosts and apparitions credible is said to consist
in the manner of telling them. The effect is gained by many literary
and conversational devices, such as the previous raising of curiosity,
the mention of little circumstances, simplicity, picturesqueness, the
naturalness of the occasion, and the like. This art is possessed by Plato
in a degree which has never been equalled.