Toleration and other essays — Voltaire — John Shaqi
Toleration and other essays
Voltaire · en
The murder of Calas, which was perpetrated with the sword of justice
at Toulouse on March 9, 1762, is one of the most singular events that
deserve the attention of our own and of later ages. We quickly forget
the long list of the dead who have perished in our battles. It is the
inevitable fate of war; those who die by the sword might themselves
have inflicted death on their enemies, and did not die without the
means of defending themselves. When the risk and the advantage are
equal astonishment ceases, and even pity is enfeebled. But when
an innocent father is given into the hands of error, of passion,
or of fanaticism; when the accused has no defence but his virtue;
when those who dispose of his life run no risk but that of making a
mistake; when they can slay with impunity by a legal decree--then the
voice of the general public is heard, and each fears for himself.
They see that no man’s life is safe before a court that has been set
up to guard the welfare of citizens, and every voice is raised in a
demand of vengeance.
In this strange incident we have to deal with religion, suicide,
and parricide. The question was, Whether a father and mother had
strangled their son to please God, a brother had strangled his
brother, and a friend had strangled his friend; or whether the judges
had incurred the reproach of breaking on the wheel an innocent
father, or of sparing a guilty mother, brother, and friend.
Jean Calas, a man of sixty-eight years, had been engaged in commerce
at Toulouse for more than forty years, and was recognised by all who
knew him as a good father. He was a Protestant, as were also his wife
and family, except one son, who had abjured the heresy, and was in
receipt of a small allowance from his father. He seemed to be so far
removed from the absurd fanaticism that breaks the bonds of society
that he had approved the conversion of his son [Louis Calas], and had
had in his service for thirty years a zealous Catholic woman, who had
reared all his children.
One of the sons of Jean Calas, named Marc Antoine, was a man of
letters. He was regarded as of a restless, sombre, and violent
character. This young man, failing to enter the commercial world,
for which he was unfitted, or the legal world, because he could
not obtain the necessary certificate that he was a Catholic,
determined to end his life, and informed a friend of his intention.
He strengthened his resolution by reading all that has ever been
written on suicide.