Femina, A Work for Every Woman — John Stuart Mill — John Shaqi
Femina, A Work for Every Woman
John Stuart Mill · en
In connection with the above comparison, in which it is shown that
Germany has proportionately less than half as many doctors as the
United States, it will be interesting to learn the views of the German
profession. The Berlin correspondent of the Medical Press writes that
the “Deutcher Ærztebund,” Society of German physicians, felt it to
be their duty to warn the guardians of young men studying in the
gymnasiums or high schools, against entering the medical profession,
the state of overcrowding being so great as to _insure disastrous_
consequences. In glancing over the above figures, there is one very
important point which is greatly in favor of the German profession and
militates against the Americans. It is the enormous patent-medicine
trade and quacking that is done through it in the United States; on the
whole, this has been calculated to amount to at least fifty per cent
of all the doctoring that is done; that means, that where one hundred
doctors now practice for a living, fifty more could make a similar
living, were it not for the patent and quack medicine trade, which, in
some of the German States, is almost prohibited, and in others I know
it is entirely inhibited.
When the Society of German physicians warns the German people that an
overcrowding “insures disastrous consequences,” what does it mean?
This is a question which, we presume, was answered in Germany, and
it is certainly worth our while that we should answer it here, and
in this we have decidedly the advantage, because in that country the
answer was entirely based upon what was anticipated, while in this
we can answer from what we have already realized, namely, disastrous
consequences to honor and to integrity on the one side, and to health
and security against imposition on the other. To this I have already
referred. Everyone competent of judging, and who has lived in that
country, knows from study and observation that the arrangements and
conveniences there for treating the sick are in a much higher state of
perfection than with us. Hospitals and physicians are as accessible to
all classes as the most humane and philanthropic heart can desire, and
now we learn that if this wholesome state of affairs shall continue
with less than half the proportion of doctors that we have here,
there must be no further increase of physicians, or it would insure
_disaster_. This statement and warning a close and careful observer
clearly appreciates. The writer was personally acquainted with a large
number of German practitioners while in that country, and knows as
an actual fact that while their fees were and are much smaller than
anything ever paid in this country, they had not overmuch to do, and
were only leisurely employed. This applies to some of the greatest
and world-renowned medical professors, as well as to the ordinary
general practitioners. But there is a reason for all this, too.
These men as a rule are honest, they are no money grabbers, they are