Notes on the Art Treasures at Penicuik House Midlothian — John Stuart Mill — John Shaqi
Notes on the Art Treasures at Penicuik House Midlothian
John Stuart Mill · en
at once crystallise intensest emotion and afford its fullest
expression, and sign and seal a human soul with final impress of
success or failure? Is—in briefest English—the man waiting for the
sign that will make him accepted or rejected lover?
This portrait, the chief treasure of Penicuik House, would surely
possess enough of interest from the power of its artistry, and the
romantic associations with which our fancy may possibly invest it; but
its interest is deepened, and it gathers a yet more intimate charm when
we have heard the beautiful old-world story connected with the lady’s
birth.
Of this curious episode there are varying versions extant, which
are given and fully discussed by Ellen K. Goodwin, in a pamphlet
(Kendal, 1886) reprinted from the “Transactions of the Cumberland
and Westmoreland Antiquarian and Archæological Society.” There is a
puzzling difference between the date of 15th November 1745, given by
Lady Clerk as the day of her birth, and that of 3d November which
appears in the register of Kirkliston parish as the day of her baptism;
but this discrepancy—we may suggest—would be lessened to within a
single day, if her Ladyship has calculated according to New Style,
introduced in Scotland in 1600, and the register has estimated by
Old Style, current in England till 1752; while the presence of the
Highlanders at Carlisle at the time would be accounted for if they
crossed the border on “the 7th or 8th of November,” New Style.
The following is the interesting version of the story, communicated by
Lady Clerk herself to the Editor of “Blackwood’s Magazine”:—