The Geneva Protocol — John Stuart Mill — John Shaqi
The Geneva Protocol
John Stuart Mill · en
Another question about a plebiscite is this: Let us concede that an
overwhelming vote such as took place in the regions of East Prussia
under the Peace Treaties is to be decisive forever. But suppose the
vote is very close; how about a vote where a little over half of the
population go one way and a trifle under half go the other? Is this
conclusive? Does it have the same moral effect as a larger vote? Is a
majority of one vote just as good as a majority of ninety per cent.?
{38}
In reality, the truth about these proposals for changing frontiers by
some sort of international procedure is that those who advocate them do
not believe in them as a general proposition. An Englishman who
believes in this sort of thing, for example, believes in it as regards
Macedonia or some such region; he does not for a moment think that such
a procedure should enable the people of British Columbia, say, to
become part of the United States. I do not mean to intimate that the
people of British Columbia have any such idea; but how is it going to
be possible to give the privilege (if it be a privilege) to people
along a few selected frontiers?
Another point, a fatal objection to such a scheme, is the inevitable
uncertainty which it would set up.
It may be a better thing to live in Manitoba than in North Dakota, or
to live in North Dakota than in Manitoba; but worse than almost any
conceivable place of residence would be a status which might change in
the future, so that one could not tell say five years ahead in what
country he was going to live. A frontier is not merely a line drawn on
a map or demarcated on the ground; a frontier means a _nexus_ of
customs, of laws, of traditions and of innumerable other things that
directly affect the daily life and conduct of every inhabitant. Any
lawyer who has had any experience in the matter will realize the
enormous difficulties that surround any transfer of territory merely in
connection with the drafting of the necessary papers[12]; and any
student who wishes to see how far-reaching the practical difficulties
may be need only consider the present situation in Alsace-Lorraine in
its bearing upon the relations between France and the Vatican.
The impossibility and the undesirability of setting up any system for
changing frontiers, such as has been discussed, are equally evident.