The Geneva Protocol — John Stuart Mill — John Shaqi
The Geneva Protocol
John Stuart Mill · en
There is another phase of this general question of the _status {39}
quo_ which is sometimes discussed by those who seem to have a natural
antipathy to the words and that is what I may call the "raw materials"
phase. There is, let us say, no coal in Switzerland, and yet
Switzerland must have coal for her people to exist. There are no oil
wells in Norway, and yet in Norway there must be, if civilization is to
continue, automotive engines. It is obvious that there can be no
physical change in such a _status quo_. People who live in the
territory that is now Switzerland must get their coal somewhere else,
and motor transport in Norway must get its gasoline from other lands.
What is the international phase of such situations as this? There are
perhaps three possibilities. One is a war of conquest commenced by a
country in the situation of Norway in order to obtain dominion over
foreign oil lands; the second is some kind of agreement such as has
been suggested in a vague way by the Italians and others for some sort
of an international supervision in such matters; and the third is that
the situation shall continue as it is now--a matter of bargain and
sale, of supply and demand.
There is not the slightest doubt in my mind that, among these three,
the first would be as impossible as it would be wicked; the second is
wholly outside the realm of practical politics for centuries to come;
the third is the _status quo_, which has not in any case of world peace
resulted in any serious injustice.
Of course, if we go beyond such cases as Norway and Switzerland and
take countries much less favored, it is always a mystery as to why
people live in them. It is very difficult to understand, for example,
why there are settlers in Labrador, or why people are fond of Greenland
as a home; none the less these things are so. And under the existing
system of exchange of commodities there has perhaps never been a time
when even the people who live in these countries without certain
particular natural resources have not generally been able to obtain
sufficient of them as a result of their own efforts in the occupations
which the character of those lands permits.
Of course some countries are naturally richer than others and {40} must
remain so. In the Delta of the Nile, the land produces as many as four
crops a year and sells for something like $3,000 an acre. Such a
condition cannot be duplicated in a climate where only one crop is
possible.