Whence arises this unreasonable custom of swaddling children? From an
unnatural custom. Since the time when mothers, despising their first
duty, no longer wish to nurse their own children at the breast, it has
been necessary to intrust the little ones to hired women. These,
finding themselves in this way the mothers of strange children,
concerning whom the voice of nature is silent to them, seek only to
spare themselves annoyance. A child at liberty would require incessant
watching; but after he is well swaddled, they throw him into a corner
without troubling themselves at all on account of his cries. Provided
there are no proofs of the nurse's carelessness, provided that the
nursling does not break his legs or his arms, what does it matter,
after all, that he is pining away, or that he continues feeble for the
rest of his life? His limbs are preserved at the expense of his life,
and whatever happens, the nurse is held free from blame.
It is pretended that children, when left free, may put themselves into
bad positions, and make movements liable to injure the proper
conformation of their limbs. This is one of the weak arguments of our
false wisdom, which no experience has ever confirmed. Of that
multitude of children who, among nations more sensible than ourselves,
are brought up in the full freedom of their limbs, not one is seen to
wound or lame himself. They cannot give their movements force enough
to make them dangerous; and when they assume a hurtful position, pain
soon warns them to change it.
We have not yet brought ourselves to the point of swaddling puppies or
kittens; do we see that any inconvenience results to them from this
negligence? Children are heavier, indeed; but in proportion they are
weaker. They can scarcely move themselves at all; how can they lame
themselves? If laid upon the back they would die in that position,
like the tortoise, without being able ever to turn themselves again.
[This want of intelligence In the care bestowed upon young children is
seen particularly in those mothers who give themselves no concern about
their own, do not themselves nurse them, intrust them to hireling
nurses. This custom is fatal to all; first to the children and finally
to families, where barrenness becomes the rule, where woman sacrifices
to her own convenience the joys and the duties of motherhood.]